If I had written this at the halfway mark it would have been 3 stars. The chopping around with the timeline wasn't working for me, and both guys needed a smack on the head every now and then; but at the end of the book I just loved it. 5 star kinda love! Kate layers her stories so beautifully, I love all her works. In this one she highlighted beautifully how different a path can be, to what is ultimately the same destination - not a right one, nor a wrong one - just different. I loved it. Loved both Adam and Jake. Just a wonderful story.